I was debating if I should put this No. 1 or 2. Nevertheless, this was an enormous win by the Badgers. Yes, I went to this game, so I am biased and feel obligated to put this right near the top. But there were so many storylines to this game. First off, Wisconsin was facing off against former defensive coordinator Dave Aranda, who bolted to LSU in the offseason. Secondly, the No. 5 Tigers came in as one of the preseason favorites to make it to the College Football Playoff, led by Heisman Trophy candidate Leonard Fournette. On the other hand, Wisconsin had to play LSU and Ohio State in Wisconsin, while playing Michigan, Michigan State and Iowa all on the road. Many, such as Colin Cowherd, predicted the Badgers to be a 6-6 team. Arnie Spanier said Wisconsin was not that good any more and that LSU would cover the massive 10.5-point spread with ease. And oh yeah, the game was at Lambeau Field, the crown jewel of all NFL stadiums. As former boxing referee Mills Lane would say, “Let’s get it on!”
College Gameday was in the house for this one. I mean, despite the fact that there were so many other great games that weekend, there was no way the show was not going to be held at Lambeau. Many called it the greatest opening weekend for college football ever. It did not disappoint. It was quite impressive that out of all the outstanding games that weekend, they chose this matchup for College Gameday. The Badgers had to replace their winningest quarterback of all-time, Joel Stave. They replaced him with senior Bart Houston, who waited for his turn despite being a highly ranked recruit coming in from California. Fittingly, Houston was named after former Packers legend Bart Starr, who had played in that stadium 50 years before. You can't make this stuff up.
In addition to Cowherd and Spanier, seemingly nobody gave the Badgers much of a chance to beat the mighty LSU Tigers. But, as Chris Berman would say, "that’s why they play the game."
Wisconsin received the opening kickoff and would get a pair of first downs on Aranda’s defense before having to punt. LSU would go three-and-out on its first possession, which was a theme for the Tigers offense in the first half. LSU would gain just 64 yards on 21 plays in the first half and four of the six drives would last three or fewer plays for the Tigers.
Twice the Badgers would drive deep into LSU territory, but would be turned away each time. On its second drive, Bucky would drive to the Tigers 23 on the strength of a Houston 21-yard pass to Rob Wheelwright. However, on the 4th-and-1, Clement would be stopped behind the line of scrimmage and the Badgers had to turn the ball over on downs. On their very next drive, Wisconsin would move into the red zone. However, on 3rd-and-9 from the LSU 10, Houston went to the right corner of the end zone intended for Kyle Penniston, but it was woefully underthrown and easily picked off by Rickey Jefferson.
It would remain scoreless until well into the second quarter. In a defensive struggle, turnovers would be magnified. They took points off the board for Wisconsin in the first quarter, but it would benefit from a big one in the second. Following a P.J. Rosowski punt, the Tigers started at their own 36. On the first play, they ran a jet sweep with running back Derrius Guice, and he was tackled and fumbled near the sideline. After a few seconds with the ball sitting on the ground, Conor Sheehy recovered for the Badgers at the 36.
This time, the scoring chance would not go to waste. Wisconsin would pick up two first downs on the drive to move down the field to the LSU 12, where the drive would stall. On the third down play, Houston threw a pass off the hands of Wheelwright in the end zone, so the Badgers had to settle for three. Rafael Gaglianone’s 30-yard field goal split the uprights and Bucky took the 3-0 lead with a little more than four minutes remaining in the first half.
Wisconsin’s defense was not done making plays in the second quarter, though. After one first down from LSU’s offense, Fournette gained nine yards on two carries to set up a 3rd-and-1. After the Heisman Trophy candidate was stuffed on third down, Les Miles decided to roll the dice on fourth down in his own territory. Fournette got the carry again, and he was stopped short of the first down by Jack Cichy and Arrington Farrar and Bucky took over on downs at the LSU 45.
Wheelwright would make his presence felt in the first half. The senior had four catches for 60 yards, three catches of which came in the first half. On the opening play of the drive, Houston found Wheelwright along the sideline, who broke a tackle and ran to the middle of the field for a 12-yard gain and a first down. That would set up Gaglianone for a 48-yard field goal, which he drilled with less than a minute left in the half. That would remain the score at the end of one half of play.
You can’t understate the job Wisconsin’s defense did in the first half. Now, no one will ever confuse LSU’s offense with the 1999 St. Louis Rams, but to hold a team to 64 yards of offense in the first half is really impressive. What is even more impressive is that they held arguably the nation’s best running back (and future top five draft pick) to just 35 yards on 11 carries. He would break off a few long runs in the second half to inflate his numbers, but for the most part, he was bottled up by a salty Wisconsin front seven. You knew LSU would not stay down for long, though.
However, the Tigers offense would pick up in the second half right where it left off in the first, going three and out and having to punt. Wisconsin would waste little time in the second half putting the first touchdown on the board. Following the LSU punt, the Badgers would travel 58 yards in less than two minutes to put them ahead by two scores. The first three plays of the drive went for first downs, starting with a 27-yard pass from Houston to tight end Troy Fumagalli to move the ball to the LSU 31. This would be the coming out party for Fumagalli. After having 500 yards receiving combined in his first two seasons, the big tight end would catch seven passes for an even 100 yards against the vaunted LSU defense. Clement would do the rest on the drive. The first three carries went for a combined 26 yards to move it to the 5. Then he would get the ball again and make a cut and fight his way into the end zone for the score. Clement was first ruled down at the 1, but after review, it was determined that he broke the plane. Bucky led 13-0.
Fournette finally made his presence felt on the next drive. He would gain 51 yards on the next four carries to move to the Wisconsin 32. But the Badgers defense would stand tall and push the Tigers back and force a punt. But that is the whole game changed.
After a few short runs from Clement set up a 3rd-and-4, Houston made a game-changing mistake. He went back to pass from his own end zone and fired a dangerous pass along the left sideline that was picked off by LSU’s Tre’Davious White, who picked it off and weaved his way 21 yards for the first Tigers score of the season.
It only got worse for the Badgers on the next drive. Even though Wisconsin still had the lead by six, the momentum was swinging to the side of the SEC school. After the kickoff, the Badgers gained one yard in two plays. On the third down, Houston found junior wide receiver George Rushing for a first down, but he would be hit and the ball came free. White recovered it for the Tigers and they were in business again at the Wisconsin 41. That was the third turnover for the Badgers and every one was painful. Thinking the defense would be on its heels after a sudden change of possession, Miles went for a shot. Brandon Harris struggled mightily on the day, only going 12-of-21 for 131 yards, but he would find a wide open Fournette down the left sideline for 31 yards. It would not take long for the Tigers to go from being down 13-0 to in front 14-13, as Harris threw a short pass to wide receiver Travin Dural, who shook free of D’Cota Dixon and waltzed into the end zone from 10 yards away. It was quite a turn of events.
The score would stay that way until late in the game. That isn’t to say there weren’t key plays, though. Starting inside linebacker T.J. Edwards broke his foot during the summer and would miss this game, so ‘Three sack’ Jack Cichy started in place of him. Already without Edwards, the other starting inside linebacker, Chris Orr, tore his ACL on the very first defensive snap of the season. Down both starting inside linebackers, former walk-on sophomore Ryan Connelly made one of the biggest plays of the game, and maybe the season. With LSU facing a 3rd-and-8 from its own 33, Miles called a screen pass. Harris threw it to Fournette and the blocking was set up nicely, but Connelly knifed through to bring down the 228-pound running back in the open field. That forced the Tigers to punt with a little more than eight minutes to play.
Wisconsin started at its own 23, looking for one of its biggest non-conference regular season wins of all-time. Houston, despite making his first start, looked as poise as you can be, completing all three passes he attempted on the drive for 38 yards. He and his big tight end got the drive rolling, as the two connected on 20-yard pass to move into Tigers territory. Backup running back Dare Ogunbowale would run for 14 yards on the the ensuing play and all of a sudden, Wisconsin was at the LSU 33. However, Paul Chryst would play it conservative and settle for the field goal attempt of 47 yards.
Gaglianone, wearing No. 27, had already hit two on the day, including one of 48. The kicker had switched his number to 27 from No. 10 to honor his friend Sam Foltz. In July of 2016, former Michigan State punter Mike Sadler and Foltz, who was entering his senior season at Nebraska, were returning from a kicking camp at Wisconsin when the car Sadler was driving lost control on wet pavement, left the road and struck a tree. Both were killed. LSU kicker Colby Delahoussaye was also in the car, but he survived and needed stitches in addition to suffering burns to his legs. It would only make sense that Gaglianone would be called upon to give Wisconsin a lead against the No. 5 team in the country late in the game.
The snap was good and Gaglianone’s kick was drilled right down the middle to give the Badgers the 16-14 lead with 3:47 remaining. It did not make it by much, but it was plenty much for the Badgers. To celebrate his big-time kick, Gaglianone pointed to his jersey. “That one was for you brother,” he tweeted after the game. “I know you were looking down and helping me make those kicks!!”
LSU had one more chance, and it was up to Wisconsin’s defense to bring home the win. The Badgers wouldn’t have had it any other way. The Tigers offense had not done much of anything to that point, gaining just 217 yards. But the drive started well for LSU, as Harris found tight end DeSean Smith for 19 yards up to the 44. Three plays later, the Tigers looked to be in business, as Harris connected with future Green Bay Packer Malachi Dupri for a first down to move to the Wisconsin 45. That was only their second third down conversion of the game. It looked even more like LSU would come out of Lambeau with a win when Fournette blasted through a hole for 15 yards before being upended by safety Leo Musso and injuring his leg. That injury would force him to miss LSU’s next game against Jacksonville State. With less than a minute and half left in the game, the Tigers were without their best player and were just whistled for a false start. Instead of being able to run the ball with confidence since Fournette was out of the game, Harris had to put the ball in the air.
Going into the season, people wondered who would replace the starting safeties from 2015, Michael Caputo and Tanner McEvoy. Those two complemented each other well. Caputo was the safety who played in the box and McEvoy was the center fielder, leading the team with six interceptions as a senior. Most of all, Caputo added leadership to a young cornerback duo. Musso had to take on more of a leadership role, and helped lead a secondary that was second in the country in interceptions. The safeties combined for nine and would make numerous big plays throughout the season. Not one was bigger than D’Cota Dixon’s in the season opener.
Harris went back to pass on the game-deciding play, and quickly was under pressure from Vince Biegel, who came in unblocked. The LSU quarterback was able to spin away from Biegel and find some space to throw. Unfortunately, for the Tigers, he rushed his throw intended for wide receiver D.J. Chark that was picked off by Dixon to seal the deal. In celebration, the safety was leveled by LSU offensive lineman Josh Boutte, which deservedly got him ejected and suspended for the following week's game. Houston took a knee three times and the Badgers emerged with a monumental win over LSU at Lambeau Field. The win was the first victory for Wisconsin over an AP top five team while unranked since 1985. It also snapped LSU’s FBS-record 52-game non-conference winning streak. The Badgers also snapped a seven game losing streak to top 10 teams.
There are no words that can describe how big this victory was. For a team that came into the season with really low expectations by Wisconsin standards, this gave them confidence that they could compete with the big boys. This win jump-started the Badgers to what would turn out to be an incredible season that would end with a victory in the Cotton Bowl in Texas.