It is about that time again. We are about a month removed
from the national championship game with Florida defeating Houston, so now it
is time for my to release my new list of top current coaches who have not made
the Final Four. From last year’s list, Jon Scheyer graduated since he made the
Final Four this season and Leonard Hamilton retired, so here is my newest list:
Honorable Mentions:
Penny Hardaway, Memphis (162-68, three NCAA Tournament
appearances)
Niko Medved, Minnesota (143-85, three NCAA Tournament
appearances)
Kevin Willard, Villanova (335-249, seven NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Sweet 16)
Andy Enfield, SMU (285-186, six NCAA Tournament appearances,
one Sweet 16, one Elite 8)
Chris Holtmann, DePaul (265-191, seven NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Sweet 16)
Steve Alford, Nevada (699-371, 13 NCAA Tournament
appearances, four Sweet 16s)
Ben Jacobsen, Northern Iowa (374-246, four NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Sweet 16)
Danny Sprinkle, Washington (122-68, three NCAA Tournament
appearances)
Fran McCaffery, Penn (548-384, 12 NCAA Tournament
appearances)
Mike Young, Virginia Tech (404-329, seven NCAA Tournament
appearances)
20. Steve Pikiell, Rutgers (344-314, three NCAA
Tournament appearances)
Even after a bad year—especially considering expectations—I
decided not to move him off him the list. With two possible top five picks, the
Scarlet Knights did not make the NCAA Tournament. While Pikiell is no doubt a
solid coach, the Scarlet Knights have just recorded 20+ wins once in nine
seasons and haven’t won more than 10 Big Ten games since 2021-22. However,
Rutgers was a dumpster fire before he arrived in Piscataway. Rutgers had not
made the Big Dance since 1991 prior to his arrival. Pikiell has turned around
the program in a big way. In 2021, he led the Scarlet Knights to their first
NCAA Tournament win since 1983 and nearly upset No. 2 seed Houston in the
second round. He had three below .500 seasons with Rutgers to start his career,
but then it all came together. Rutgers had only once made back-to-back NCAA
Tournament appearances (1975-76) before making it to two straight seasons in
2021 and 2022. Before going to New Jersey, he had a big turnaround at Stony
Brook, winning just four games in his first year to a program that reached the
postseason in six of his final seven seasons, culminating with an NCAA
Tournament appearance in 2016.
19. Ed Cooley, Georgetown (361-261, seven NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Sweet 16)
Cooley made a big improvement this season from year one to
year two at Georgetown. After leading the Hoyas to two wins in league play in
year one, Cooley led Georgetown to eight wins in Big East play, the most since
2018-19 when the Hoyas recorded nine league wins in Patrick Ewing’s second
season at the helm. In his first five tournament appearances, his team only
advanced past the first round once, but made it to the second weekend in 2022
and put a scare into eventual national champion Kansas and actually had the
lead with under six minutes to play. Cooley will have the Hoyas as a perennial
NCAA Tournament team shortly under Cooley.
18. Pat Kelsey, Louisville (288-130, five NCAA Tournament
appearances)
There should be no surprise he is on the list. Most may
argue that he should be higher, and I could definitely buy that. Kelsey turned
around a Louisville team from eight wins in 2023-24 the year before he came to
27 in his first year, a trip to the ACC Tournament title game and an NCAA
Tournament berth. For his efforts, he was named ACC Coach of the Year. He
started his collegiate head coaching career at Winthrop, where he turned around
a team that had 12 wins the season before he arrived to a 23-2 mark in his
final season, which earned the Eagles a No. 12 seed in the NCAA Tournament. He
took a job at College of Charleston in 2021-22 and all he did was lead the Cougars
to a pair of conference titles and tournament berths, where it helped him earn
the job at Louisville. The Cardinals have a good one in Kelsey, who could leave
this list shortly with all the materials at his disposal with the Cardinals.
17. Mark Byington, Vanderbilt (239-146, two NCAA
Tournament appearances)
In year one, Mark Byington had a sensational year one for
Vanderbilt, leading the Commodores to 20 wins in his first season in Nashville
and their first trip to the NCAA Tournament since 2017. During year one, Vanderbilt
posted five victories against top 25 teams, including four against top 15
opponents. He took over a program that had only two winning seasons in five
years under Jerry Stackhouse. Prior to coming over to Vanderbilt, he spent four
seasons at James Madison, where he led the Dukes to 82 victories, including 32
in 2023-24, leading them to the second round of the NCAA Tournament. Before
JMU, he led Georgia Southern to 131-97 in seven seasons, including three
straight 20-win seasons to finish his tenure with the Eagles. It will be
interesting to see how he does with Vanderbilt going forward in the brutal SEC.
16. Kevin Young, BYU (26-10, one NCAA Tournament
appearance, one Sweet 16)
Young had some big shoes to fill, following the departure of
Mark Pope to Kentucky. He did so in a big way, leading the Cougars to their
first Sweet 16 appearance since 2011 before Alabama made approximately 700
3-pointers—at least it seemed that way, anyway—to send BYU home. In the brutal
Big 12, he led BYU to a 14-6 record in league play. This is his first college
head coaching job after spending more than a decade in the NBA and the NBA
G-League. An interesting note on Wikipedia about him…he is the great-great-great-great-grandson
of Lorenzo Young, the brother of BYU's founder and namesake, Brigham Young. It
doesn’t mean anything, but I found it interesting. With the NIL money flowing
into the school, it would not shock me to see Young reach the Final Four in the
not-too-distant future.
15. Grant McCasland, Texas Tech (403-141, three NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Elite 8)
Grant McCasland makes his debut on the list after leading
Texas Tech to an appearance in the Elite 8, where they could not hold a
nine-point lead in the final three minutes and lost to eventual national
champion Florida. The Gators finished the contest on an 18-4 spurt to send them
to the Final Four and leave the Red Raiders to think what could have been.
Still, Texas Tech made major strides in year two under McCasland after falling
in the first round of the NCAA Tournament in year one. He’ll have a heck of an
opportunity this season with reigning Big 12 Player of the Year and
All-American JT Toppin returning for the 2025-26 season. While with the Mean
Green, he compiled a 135-65 mark, making the postseason four times, including
one NCAA Tournament berth in which they upset Purdue in overtime and made the
second round. In his final season in Denton, he guided UNT to the NIT title. He
has things moving in the right direction in Lubbock.
14. Ben McCollum, Iowa (426-95, one NCAA Tournament
appearance)
McCollum is making his first appearance on this list after a
fantastic year in his only season at Drake after coming over from Northwest
Missouri State (Division II), where he built a dynasty, compiling a 395-91 mark
and four national championships in his last eight years and it could have been
five if COVID hadn’t forced a cancellation of that season’s tournament. He
brought over Bennett Stirtz and the Bulldogs rolled to a 31-4 record and upset
of Missouri in the first round. Now he takes over a middling Iowa team that
hasn’t reached the second weekend of the NCAA Tournament this millennium. If
anyone can do it, McCollum can. It is a brutal Big Ten now with the additions
of the four Pac 12 schools, but on the surface, the Hawkeyes made a home run
hire this offseason,
13. Jamie Dixon, TCU (504-249, 14 NCAA Tournament
appearances, two Sweet 16s, one Elite 8)
Dixon has been a great coach for a number of years, from
Pittsburgh to TCU. After 328 wins at Pitt, he took his talents to his alma
mater and has not skipped a beat. Before a down season this past year, he won
at least 20 games in each of the prior three seasons, bringing relevance to a
program that was a dumpster fire before he got there. Even in a down season, he
still finished .500 and his ninth-place finish in the Big 12 is as good as
Trent Johnson did. He took over a dormant program after Johnson couldn’t win in
his four years with the program. TCU only had one winning season and was a
combined 8-64 in conference play, never finishing higher than ninth in the
conference. Prior to Dixon, TCU had not made either the NCAA Tournament or NIT
since 2005, and not made the Big Dance this millennium. The one thing he needs
to improve upon is his 69-93 mark in league play, never finishing above .500.
12. Will Wade, North Carolina State (246-105, seven NCAA
Tournament appearances, one Sweet 16)
It was just a matter of time before Wade decided to move on
to a bigger job. Not before he made his mark on McNeese, though, leading the
Cowboys to an upset of Clemson in the first round of the NCAA Tournament. The
marriage could not have gone much better for Wade and McNeese, as Wade repaired
his image while leading McNeese to two of its best seasons in program history.
Wade had a terrific stint with LSU prior to McNeese, leading the Tigers to 105
victories in not quite five full seasons, including an SEC championship and
Sweet 16 appearance in 2019. Between McNeese and LSU, he would have led his
teams to NCAA Tournament appearances in each of his last six seasons, as the
Tigers would have made it in during the COVID season. I don’t doubt he’ll have
the Wolfpack ready to go and compete for an ACC crown soon, especially if the
league was as down as it was last season.
11. Randy Bennett, St. Mary’s (562-222, 11 NCAA
Tournament appearances, one Sweet 16)
Bennett has been a mainstay in college basketball for years
and has put together one of the most consistently good programs in the country.
He is coming off leading the Gaels to one of their best seasons ever, winning 29
games and the West Coast Conference regular season title. The 29 victories are
the second-most in program history. Unfortunately for him and St. Mary’s, it
didn’t translate to as much NCAA Tournament success as it hoped for, as the
Gaels lost to Alabama in the second round of the Big Dance. That has been a
theme for Bennett. With the exception of the COVID-shortened season, SMC has
won at least 20 games every year since 2007-08, including at least 25 wins on 14
occasions in that time period. However, the Gaels have reached the Sweet 16
just once in that time—in 2009-10. He has been a remarkable regular season
coach, but will he be a coach who can’t win the big one or finally make a run
and make the trip to the Final Four after so many misses Matt Painter, Tony
Bennett or Bo Ryan. When Bennett arrived in 2001, he inherited a program that
went 2-27 and has turned it into one of top mid-major programs in the country.
It will be interesting to see if he can finally make that run.
10. Mark Pope, Kentucky (211-120, three NCAA Tournament
appearances, one Sweet 16)
Pope took the job at his alma mater and ran with it, guiding
Kentucky to a Sweet 16 appearance in his first season at the helm. After four
20-win seasons in five years, he led the Wildcats to 24 wins and a No. 3 seed
in the NCAA Tournament. The Sweet 16 berth was amazingly the first appearance
in the second weekend for the Wildcats since 2019. I think he will eventually
get his Wildcats to the Final Four, but if he doesn’t, it won’t be for a lack
of resources since it is rumored that Kentucky will have an NIL budget of more
than $20 million.
9. Greg Gard, Wisconsin (212-117, seven NCAA Tournament
appearances, two Sweet 16s)
It was a terrific coaching job by Gard this season. Gone
were leading scorer AJ Storr and long-time starters Tyler Wahl and Chucky
Hepburn. All Gard did was lead the Badgers to an even better season in 2024-25
behind All-American John Tonje, a guy who was originally transferring to New
Mexico after getting injured and missing most of the previous season for
Missouri. In addition to Tonje’s emergence, a group of Nolan Winter, John
Blackwell, Carter Gilmore and Kamari McGee took major leaps under the new-and-improved
offense, one that dropped 116 (!!!!) points in a 31-point beatdown of Iowa in
January. However, the one monkey on his back is that he has not made the second
weekend since 2017. This season, it was a two-point defeat at the hands of
hot-shooting BYU. On paper, this looks like a better transfer group coming in,
but it will be hard to replace three seniors, including Tonje, as well as most
of the bench. But with his new offense, the arrow is pointed up for Gard and
the Badgers.
8. Buzz Williams, Maryland (373-228, 11 NCAA Tournament
appearances, three Sweet 16s, one Elite 8)
Buzz Williams spent five or six seasons in each of his last
three stops: Marquette, Virginia Tech and Texas A&M. After six years with
the Aggies and three NCAA Tournament appearances, he decided it was time to
move on. With jobs in the Big East, ACC and SEC now complete, he chose to take
a job in the Big Ten and is heading to Maryland. His Aggies recorded four
consecutive seasons of at least 20 wins, but none of three NCAA Tournament
teams made it past the first weekend. Before A&M, he had a strong season with
Virginia Tech. With the Hokies, he led them to the Sweet 16 for the first time
since 1966-67 and nearly knocked off Duke. Before Virginia Tech, he averaged
more than 23 wins per season with Marquette and made the Sweet 16 twice and an
Elite 8. The former Mike McConathy assistant has a good program and will keep
Maryland toward the top of the Big Ten for years to come.
7. Brad Underwood, Illinois (274-128, nine NCAA
Tournament appearances, one Elite 8)
Underwood has been a consistently good coach, leading the
Illinois to one of the best records in the Big Ten every single year, but he
struggles to make the second weekend, much less the Final Four. He and
Wisconsin’s Greg Gard are in a similar boat. This past year, his team was
bounced in the second round by Kentucky in a friendly home environment in
Milwaukee. In 2024, he advanced to the Elite 8 for the first time before being
blasted by UConn. This past season, his team dealt with sickness and injuries. It
will be interesting to see how the team bounces back this year. After an
incredible run at Stephen F. Austin in which he led the Lumberjacks to an 89-14
record and an incredible 53-1 conference record, he led the Oklahoma State
Cowboys to the tournament in 2017. It feels like just a matter of time for
Underwood to break through, although I say it with a lot of the coaches on this
list.
6. Eric Musselman, USC (238-111, six NCAA Tournament
appearances, two Sweet 16s, two Elite 8s)
After a down year in his first season at USC and the Big
Ten, Musselman moves down a bit, but he is still well inside the top 10.
However, Musselman has two straight seasons with below .500 records and three
straight with under .500 records during conference play. Still, he showed up
during NCAA Tournament berth, as he led the Arkansas Razorbacks to three
straight seasons in the second weekend post-COVID, including two Elite 8
appearances. Even at 22-14, he led his No. 9 seed Razorbacks to the Sweet 16.
Before landing in Fayetteville, he turned around a Nevada program that posted
just nine wins in the season prior to his arrival. In his first season there,
he led Nevada to a 15-win increase in 2015-16 and a CBI championship. In his
next three seasons, he led them to three consecutive NCAA Tournament
appearances and a berth in the Sweet 16 in 2018.
5. Greg McDermott, Creighton (630-366, 13 NCAA Tournament
appearances, two Sweet 16s)
McDermott has turned Creighton into a true force. He has led
the Blue Jays to at least 20 wins in all but one of his seasons in Omaha,
including 25 in each of his past two seasons. In the five seasons since the
COVID year, he has led the Blue Jays to an Elite 8 appearance and two berths in
the Sweet 16. Last year, they were a No. 9 seed and dominated Louisville in the
first round before giving Auburn all it could handle before falling. Ryan
Kalkbrenner is gone, but Creighton will be back at it again. The future is
bright for McDermott and he will continue to be in the upper echelon of the Big
East.
4. Chris Mack, College of Charleston (302-142, eight NCAA
Tournament appearances, three Sweet 16s, one Elite 8)
Chris Mack is back for another season at the College of
Charleston after leading the Cougars to a 24-9 record, trying to build on what
Pat Kelsey built before taking the Louisville job last offseason. His two best
years at Xavier, in 2015-16 and 2017-18, were spoiled before the second weekend
by Wisconsin and Florida State, respectively. He hasn’t made the second weekend
since 2017 and probably won’t at Charleston. Despite his failure at Louisville,
Mack is a heck of a coach who will be back with a power program soon.
3. T.J. Otzelberger, Iowa State (194-108, six NCAA
Tournament appearances, two Sweet 16s)
After a so-so tenure at UNLV, his stock has only gone up
since coming to Iowa State. He has won 95 games in his first three seasons in
Ames, including 25 this past year. Otzelberger has led ISU to the NCAA
Tournament in all four years with two appearances in the Sweet 16. The Cyclones
were a juggernaut once again this season before injuries hit them and dropped
them to a No. 3 seed and falling in the second round. Starting 17-2, Iowa State
was hit the injury bug before going 8-8 the rest of the season. If the Cyclones
were healthy all year, they could have made it to the Final Four this past
season, but I think TJ will make it eventually.
2. Tommy Lloyd, Arizona (112-33, four NCAA Tournament
appearances, three Sweet 16s)
All Tommy Lloyd has done with the Arizona Wildcats is win.
He has not reached an Elite 8 like his predecessor at Arizona—and No. 1 on this
list—Sean Miller did, but still, 112 wins in four years (28 per season) is
impressive. After a sluggish start to the season, he rebounded the Wildcats to
a No. 4 seed in the NCAA Tournament and a spot in the Sweet 16, not to mention
a pair of conference regular season titles. He was looked at as a rising star
in the coaching profession at Gonzaga and the possible heir apparent once Mark
Few retired. There is still a lot of time before the start of the season, but
Arizona looks to be in prime position to have another strong season. It just
seems like it is a matter of time before he reaches the Final Four. I will say,
though, I said that about Sean Miller a number of times, so we’ll see.
1. Sean Miller, Texas (487-196, 13 NCAA Tournament
appearances, five Sweet 16s, four Elite 8s)
It did not take long for Sean Miller to be back in a power
conference. After three years at Xavier with a pair of NCAA Tournament
appearances, Miller was hired at Texas. He’ll have all the resources he needs
to try to complete what he did at Arizona. Before being fired by Arizona, he
was a monster there, going 302-109 in 12 seasons, winning at least 30 games
four times. He led the Wildcats to the Elite 8 on four occasions. Arguably his
two best teams ran into Frank Kaminsky in both 2014 and 2015. He has been so
close before, leading his teams to nine trips to the second weekend and four to
the Elite, but cannot make that final step. Sean Miller is too good of a coach
to finish his career without a berth in the Final Four. He’ll step into a
loaded conference, one in which boasts the national champion Florida Gators, so
it will be interesting to see how her fares.